Choose a topic

.. Cognition
General Artificial Intelligence
Observing My Experience

.. HUM
A Mind

Culture is Ordinary

AI and Art
Art in the Age of Mechanical Reproduction
Excellence is a Plateau
Is this picture real?
NonFungible Tokens
Public Art
Tearing Down Statues
What is Art?
Working With Reality

Artificial Intelligence and the Collingridge Dilemma.
Bird Brains
Bounded Rationality
Competence Without Comprehension
Consciousness is More Like Fame Than Television
Developmental Processes
Emergence and Cognition
Gender dysphoria
I Lost My Knife
Incomplete Information and Stories
Intelligence and Motivation
Is free will an illusion?
Natural Law
Necessary Illusions
On Affordances
Pencil and Paper
Post Phenomenology
Reflective Equilibrium
Return of the Law of Forms
Shifting Meanings
Structures of Understanding
Taking Things on Faith
The Hard Problem
The I Love You Gesture
The Imagined Order
The Phenomenology of Swim Bladders.
Thinking about medical procedures
Thinking About Risk
Underdetermination and Redundancy
What Could Possibly Go Wrong?
What Does Google Know?
What is going on?

A Country Is Not Like A Company
Alternate ideas lying around waiting for disaster
Blood and Money
Can Capitalism Survive?
Do Our Minds Own Our Bodies?
Everyday Communism
Invisible Hand
Job Creators
Job Destroyers
Money and Value
Money is Different
National Accounts
Necessary Production
Paper Wealth
Post Capitalist Society
Profit Motive Fails
Rentier Capitalism
Social Wealth vs Surplus Value
Spending Money Into Existence
The Metaphysics of Money
The Ontology of Debt
Thinking about Money
Wealth is What Money Buys

Blowing Up Pipelines

Absolute Knowledge
I do not know everything
Lies, Damned Lies, and Statistics
Rethinking Knowledge
Rethinking Knowledge
Semiotics and Body Language
The Curious Ineffectiveness of Facts
The Past and the Future.
Uncertainty and Unpredictability
Whatever happened to The Truth?

Body Plans
Competition and Cooperation
Dr Malthus would be pleased
Error Correction
Evolution Defended
Evolution is not Religion
Evolution of Cars
Forces of Nature
Is Natural Selection Obsolete?
Politics and Evolution
The Evolution of Purpose.
The Problem with Natural Selection.
The Source of Bad Behavior
Thinking about Tails
Why Does a Leopard Have Spots?

Free Speech in the age of Twitter
Freedom and Badness
Freedom and Morality
Freedom From and Freedom To
Freedom in the Age of Convoys
Libertarian Coercion

10 Views of Landscape
Affect and Effect
I pay rent.
Listening to Corn
The Reform vs Revolution Paradox
What is Public Schooling For?

Levels of Abstraction
Levels of Abstraction and Minds
What is a newspaper?

As Much As Possible
Zipfs Law

Emotional Plague
Memes: Imitated Behavior.
The Problem with Memes
What is a replicator?

Beyond Rules Based Morality
Freedom and Morality
Moral Realism.
What do we owe animals?


Maps and Territories
Metaphysics Without Absolutes
Philosophy Buds
Sincerely Held Beliefs
Sorites Paradox
Stereoscopic Vision and The Hard Problem
The Gorilla in the Room of Science
The Purpose of Science
What is Going On?

If It Walks Like a Duck
Right Wing Freedom
The Sovereign Citizen
Tyranny of the Majority


Constructed Life
Correlation Wins
Quack Doctors
The Great Shattering
The Material Space
Thinking about Interconnection
Too Small to See
Watching Pigeons
Weirdness in Physics

A Job
A society needs a government.
Babies and Bathwater
Belly of the Beast
Cultural Appropriation
Drag Story Tellers
Family Values
Governance and Power
Griefers and Misinformation and Disinformation
I Distrust the News
Inclusion and Christmas
Its a Free Country
Life Extension
Moral Decline
Open Society and Falsification
Parents, Children, and Community
Rethinking Rights
Rules in a Knife Fight?
Sex and Gender
Should We Go to Mars?
Social vs Individual Responsibility.
Society and The State
Society evolved
Spheres of Influence
The Care and Feeding of Free Speech
The Collingridge Dilemma
The Common Good
The Dual Meaning of Power
The Homeless
The Problem with Hedonism
The Rule of Law.
Thoughts on Justice
To the Moon
Trial by jury
Virtue Signalling
We Live in the Present
What is to be said?
What made freedom a bad word?
Why is there a shortage of nurses?
Work - Productive, Useful, Worthless, and Bad.

Implications of Very Productive Technology
Modest Proposal
Problems with Universal Basic Income
Tormenting Unlucky People
Why there are oligarchs

Competence Without Comprehension

How is it done?

From Bacteria to Bach and Back - Daniel Dennett Philosophy and Simulation - Manuel Delanda Sapiens - Yuval Noah Harari

A common thread in these thinkers is to consider how cognitive capacities like comprehension can arise. Dennett deals with the topic quite directly. Delanda explores the sorts of digital simulations that are required to deal with the sorts of things we deal with like pattern matching and decision making. Harari explores how things like morality or language could emerge in a lineage that started with neither.

To put it clearly; a neuron (say) does not comprehend but a well functioning brain, that is a huge network of neurons, does comprehend. A neuron may not comprehend, but stimulation causes it's state to change. But this change of state occurs in a system where the change of state becomes stimulation for other neurons and a cascade of stimulation and state change propagates within the system.

This process may be chaotic but it is not random. A particular neuron will only change its state (which affects other neurons) if a certain set of conditions is met. This is called 'firing'. That set of conditions is created by evolution and experience, but I'd call the capacity to fire when a particular set of conditions is met a competence. Within the context of the network of neurons the firing has meaning. Within the network the functional purpose of that firing is to signal that certain conditions have been met. Other neurons get the signal and fire in turn if the set of signals they get meets their own set of conditions.

A competence is the ability to do something meaningful within a system if conditions are met. This is different from a purely physical change like ice melting to water if it's warmed.

A neuron doesn't comprehend; it just fires when conditions are met. And yet we comprehend. And there is a level of comprehension we share with other mobile animals that is not associated with being conscious. A frog snapping up a fly comprehends the fly in a way that none of it's neurons do. But there is no thought process of "Ahhh - a black spot that's a fly! Must snap it up!" But there is a comprehension of what the spot means and the response follows. And the comprehension enables a further competence; the ability to snap up a fly.

What we are seeing here is how comprehension emerges from the competences of things that do not comprehend. The idea of emergence is a meme that has evolved into many different forms so I must be clear about what I mean here so I digress a bit.

Let's start with a level of physical reality like subatomic particles. They have properties that cause them to combine and associate in various ways that we call atoms. The atoms have properties that the subatomic particles do not have. The properties that atoms have that subatomic particles do not have are emergent properties. The subatomic particles and the atoms are at different levels of abstraction. Atoms produce matter in its various forms - ie liquid solid or gas, and the various chemical elements - another emergent level of abstraction. Biology emerges from chemistry, and so on.

Consider the bicycle in the context of emergence. A bicycle is made of physical stuff. Let's call the pile of parts needed to make a bicycle a level of abstraction. If we assemble the parts properly we get a new level of abstraction that is the bicycle. The bicycle has properties the pile of parts did not have. You can ride a bicycle. You could not ride the pile of parts. We can say that a new property has emerged; let's call it rideability. Rideability emerges from physical reality but is not a physical thing with mass or color or charge. But it is real, as real as the metal a bicycle is made of.

Returning to the frog. The ability to comprehend that a fly is present emerges from the lower level of the frog's neural network. DeLanda shows how properties like pattern matching emerge from simple neural networks. Then he explores what happens when you treat those simple networks as elements from which further levels of abstraction emerge. He also explores what happens when you let systems like that compete in an evolutionary environment. He explores systems that have a level of comprehension in a virtual reality similar to our frog.

Both Dennett and Harari discuss our own level of comprehension as emerging not only from our brains but also from our interactions with other individuals and with social institutions.

A practical problem with this kind of analysis is that since ancient times we have thought of competence as requiring comprehension. For instance a competent welder comprehends what they are doing - that is, the comprehension is a lower level of abstraction from which competence emerges. But was that ever right? Who ever learned to weld from a textbook?

What do you think?

Star I present regular philosophy discussions in a virtual reality called Second Life. I set a topic and people come as avatars and sit around a virtual table to discuss it. Each week I write a short essay to set the topic. I show a selection of them here.

I've been thinking and reading about philosophy for a long time but I'm mostly self taught. That is I've had the good fortune to read what interests me rather than follow a course of study. That has it's limits of course but advantages. It doesn't cost as much and is fun too.

My interests are things like evolution and cognition and social issues and economics and science in general.